Critique Circle is an online writing workshop for all authors, whether they write literary fiction, genre fiction, articles or short stories. It will express your best interest—especially if you had a lot of hard things to say.
Do you know what the writer was critiquing someone writing a story to show you? Suggested Critique Format Below is a format that we have found to work well for giving critiques.
Answering this kind of question is what helps you as a writer. Remember how you judge a book or story when you first see it in a bookstore. Did we get the chance to interpret what the characters were feeling or did the author just tell us directly?
For example, I once wrote "fruits of mother nature" and "thoughts burning in his mind", both of which are cliches. I critique in Word with Track Changes, which makes it so much easier to crit a piece of work. What else did I need to know?
Halfway through, do you want to keep reading? Conversely, does it have too many subplots and you got confused about what was happening? It was of good value to me as it got me started thinking more deeply about my characters.
It will also save you the need to explain such exotic topics as point of view, theme, and development of plot and character. Reading as a writer is always going to feed into your own work. Try to give yourself over to the piece. Could I follow the piece, or were there gaps, or need for more information?
Did I want to keep reading? Give examples from the piece whenever possible to show your points.
I always appreciate a suggestion for fixing something. If you are not interested in reading on, why not?
This is important because it tells the author how well he or she has succeeded in communicating. In fact, some of the suggestions you get are likely to be not-so-useful.
Has the writer threaded in the details well enough? Do you as a critic have a good idea of the type of readers this author was writing for? Every writer likes to be praised, especially by those not obligated to praise them due to marital status or having given birth to them.
Highlight the strong points of a piece—even if they are far outweighed by the negative points. Stir up as many levels of conflict and problems for your protagonist hero as you can. There is no safer environment to honestly and succinctly point out problem areas in a piece of writing than a forum designed for that very purpose.
There was no consideration of author intent, only reader interpretation.Some people combine these two stages or steps, and process their response to a piece very quickly. This certainly may be appropriate in some cases.
The danger it is that you may stop at the first stage and not want to do the harder work of actually critiquing a piece. It may be that you don’t feel trained or qualified as a critic. Part of writing great critiques is learning to spot the gems in the story and encouraging the writer to press onward in spite of any shortcomings.
If you’re honest and genuine, this won’t be a problem. Nor does critique mean criticizing. I read your story keeping in mind its elements—that is, character, dialogue, setting, style, structure, and, perhaps most important, whether or not your story has heart. Writing well means going deep.
It means writing from a place of authenticity and freedom. It is sometimes tempting to change someone else's piece to make it more like something YOU would have written.
Instead, help the writer produce the best possible version of what THAT WRITER is trying to write. Rewrite the story the way yOU would have written it; How to Write a Critique: Advice on Receiving a Critique. Aug 20, · Your critique will be more effective if you have a background in the genre or area of the writing, such as being an avid reader of science fiction if asked to critique someone's science fiction manuscript%(32).
Fact: writing is a skill that will take years to perfect. Very few writers write a masterpiece on the first draft. In fact, authors will go through numerous revisions to get a draft to even resemble something worth marketing/pitching.Download